In a time where takeout options abound, there’s an unparalleled charm in the simplicity of pizza night. As we navigate the myriad of culinary choices, our hearts, or perhaps stomachs, consistently gravitate towards the comforting allure of a well-crafted pizza. Here are our top picks in East Gwillimbury—each pie offering a distinct and delectable experience that transforms an ordinary evening into a feast of flavor.
1. Papa D’s Pizza
Address: 1513 Mount Albert Rd, Newmarket, ON, Canada, Ontario
Phone: (905) 478-8844
Photo by Papa D’s Pizza
Papa D’s Pizza in Sharon has been a local favorite for 15 years. Renowned for being the best in town, Papa D’s goes beyond traditional offerings, presenting unique Korean-style pizzas such as Kimchi and Bulgogi. A standout recommendation is their sweet potato pizza, a savory delight that has patrons driving 45 minutes from Toronto just to experience its exquisite taste.
2. Santa Fe
Address: 19415 Yonge St, Holland Landing, ON L9N 1L8
Phone: (905) 953-1800
Photo by Santa Fe
In 1997, John and Anna opened the doors to Santa Fe Pizza in the charming village of Holland Landing. This “Ma & Pa” business quickly became a local favorite, crafting pizzas with a unique blend of fresh ingredients, tangy sauce, and handmade dough. The crust, often likened to homemade, and the premium blend of mozzarella cheese create a signature pizza experience. Santa Fe Pizza thrives on offering a distinct taste in a sea of mass-produced alternatives.
3. Cocelli’s
Address: 18279 Yonge St #3, East Gwillimbury, ON L9N 0A2
Phone: (905) 898-0888
Photo by Cocelli’s
At Cocelli’s, everything is crafted at home, ensuring that each meal is made to order. Their pizza crust is celebrated for its perfect crispiness, complemented by fresh and flavorful toppings. Customers also highly recommend exploring their homemade pasta and meatballs. An excellent value awaits with Cocelli’s special: $53 for 2 large pizzas, 3 toppings on each, 10 wings, and 1 pasta—a feast that satisfies both taste buds and wallets.
4. Lemar’s Pizza
Address: 95 Holland St W, Bradford, ON L3Z 2B5
Phone: (905) 775-2222
Photo by Lemar’s Pizza
Tucked away in Bradford, Lemar’s Pizza is a hidden gem that captures the essence of community and passion. A locally owned establishment, Lemar’s has earned a stellar reputation, drawing customers who willingly drive over an hour to savor its offerings. Described as “not overpriced cardboard” like most chains, Lemar’s is a testament to authentic, flavorful pizza. Customers particularly praise the exceptional quality of the sauce, elevating their dining experience.
5. Frano Pizza & Panini
Address: 19364 ON-48, Mount Albert, ON L0G 1M0
Phone: (905) 473-2020
Photo by Frano Pizza & Panini
Founded in 1967, Frano Pizza & Panini has become a cornerstone of the pizza landscape. Rooted in a rich family history that traces back to Sicily, this establishment has spent decades perfecting its pizza crust and marinara sauce. The result? A match made in heaven that captivates taste buds with its crunch, chew, and rich flavors. Beyond pizza, Frano Pizza & Panini offers an array of delectable options, from authentic Italian hot-table selections to mouthwatering calzones.
Customers commend the business for its authentic, family-run approach, with owners Frank and Maria, along with their dedicated children, ensuring that every item is made from scratch. Visitors rave about the meat lovers pizza and the delightful garlic knots, elevating their experience to a solid 10/10.
